A clear over-reaction

February was a turbulent month, fuelled by fears of a coronavirus pandemic. Carnegie Global fell 7.5 percent.

By the weekend of February 22-23, it was clear the coronavirus had gained a foothold outside China. The week after, the stock market began to price in a global spread and the MSCI World equity index fell 12 percent in the last five days of the month. Is it reasonable for global stocks to lose around USD 4 trillion due to the coronavirus? Let us see.

A company is worth all its future cash flows discounted back to today. We often talk about P/E and similar valuation metrics, but these are really just simplifications of a cash flow analysis. A cash flow analysis quickly makes it clear that a company’s value hinges largely on what happens in ten years and further ahead. This means that factors with only a short-term impact have just a small effect on a company’s value.

I believe the economic worst case from the virus is that companies’ growth completely disappears in 2020. The IMF estimates a reduction in global growth from 3.3 percent to 3.2 percent, so my scenario is like Armageddon compared to the IMF analysis. In a cash flow analysis that initially assumes 1) 3 percent annual growth in dividends in perpetuity, and 2) a 10 percent discount interest rate, the value of a company would decrease by 2.9 percent.

This is worth repeating: if companies do not grow at all this year, their value falls by only 2.9 percent. Short-term impacts are not as important as one might imagine when it comes to the value of a company. The 12 percent fall at the end of February means that the market expects company profits to not grow by a single krona in five (!) years. Not even if all listed companies in the world fail to make a single krona in 2020 is a 12 percent fall justified.

It seems clear to me that the market has over-reacted to the coronavirus, and I believe this is a good time for us long-term investors to buy fine companies at better valuations than those on offer just a month ago.

More about the fund

Global A

Carnegie Global är en aktivt förvaltad aktiefond för dig som vill spara långsiktigt i några av världens bästa bolag. Målet med Carnegie Global är att den ska fungera som bas...

More info
Buy fund

More articles

An attractive transition case

An attractive transition case

Carnegie Global rose 1.31 percent in December. Currency effects were negative and reduced the return by 0.91 percent. For full-year 2019, the fund rose 24.1 percent. Currency effects across the...

Mikael Tarnawski-Berlin 7 January 2020
Using macro analysis to win on stocks

Using macro analysis to win on stocks

Iran, trade wars, Trump’s latest tweet and Brexit. Anyone who reads the news can easily get the impression that the future looks bleak and that it is time to exit...

Mikael Tarnawski-Berlin 2 October 2019
Values – Carnegie Fonder’s Sustainability Report

Values – Carnegie Fonder’s Sustainability Report

Focus is increasingly on sustainability. The concerns are rarely new to Carnegie Fonder because it has always been important to us to invest in companies for the long term and...

Hans Hedström 1 October 2019